Response on Eisner and Thompson

I feel like Craig Thompson and Will Eisner all have their unique approach of creating their comic. While reading their comics, I noticed a variety of visual similarities and differences with the two artists’ styles:



I like the style art and storytelling for both artists. However, I think Will Eisner’s work affected me more on a personal level. I felt like Will Eisner’s representation of the life of the poor and minority and ethnic identity in the “contract with god” has a very strong emotional impact to the audience. It affected me both because of his realistic, but exaggerated art style and also the fact that the story is not in traditional comic book panels. In "contract with god", Some of the panels are almost picture book like while other panels are designed with the shape and sizes just for expressing the character’s emotions. I feel like this dynamic way of arranging the comic panels help to create more possibility to impact the reader emotionally. While I was reading, I tend to think less about the logic of the plots and lean twoards feeling the emotions of the characters. I think I would be interested to look into more of his work to learn from his art style in my free time.

Comments

  1. Cindy Li's BlogFebruary 28, 2020 at 9:46 PM

    I like how you make a graph and compare and contrast two artists. It's simple and clear. And it's interesting how you notice how Eisner arranged the pictures and how that could help make connections with the readers.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dr. David SteilingFebruary 29, 2020 at 7:53 PM

    I too, liked your Venn diagram of the intersecting traits of Eisner and Craig Thompson.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Response on Persepolis

Image
I like the point of view and the visual language of Persepolis. In Persepolis, the POV is focused on Marjane herself, making her the main character growing up from childhood to adulthood in the times of war. I like it because it is much more impactful and also entertaining to see the effect of war and pressure of society form a young girl's point of view than history books. It reminds me of the feeling of reading "The Diary of Anne Frank". Both characters are telling their story of living in wartime and from oppression by their leaders. Persepolis let me understood a lot about Inequality, and lack of freedom, and especially women's rights at the time period. The strong visual and verbal representation used in the graphic novel is very impactful to me. Visually, I found this panel in page 95 is very impactful. The composition is repetitive, enhancing the fact that every woman is forced to be the same. The mass amount of black used in the image creates a depressi...
Read more

Response on Understanding Comics

Understanding Comics by Scott McCloud informs the reader about the medium of comic - juxtaposed sequential visual art - using a various interesting methods. What stands out to me the most is his method of using the comic medium itself to explain the knowledge and secrets behind comics. I think this way of providing information is very entertaining, it’s like telling a story within a story rather than reading plain text that explains the mechanics of comics. Most of the panels uses a simplified cartoony style with notan shading and inked line, however, when he explains the different style of drawings, he changes the style of drawing in his panels in order to visually explain the style that he is talking about. I found it very entertaining to see a very realistically sketched character standing right next to a super cartoony narrator. One idea that I found very interesting is the idea of amplification through simplification in pictorial icons. I feel like this idea strongly resemble...
Read more